Data Protection Commissioner
Data Protection Commissioner

Irish High Court grants the Data Protection Commissioner its CJEU referral in DPC v Facebook Ireland and Maximilian Schrems


The Commissioner welcomes the High Court’s judgment and its decision to refer a number of questions to the CJEU, as requested by the Commissioner.

The transfer of personal data to the US under the standard contractual clauses mechanism (“SCCs”) raises important issues for the protection of EU citizens’ data protection rights. Now that the High Court has confirmed it shares the Commissioner’s concerns about the protection of those rights in the context of EU/US data transfers, the Commissioner hopes these issues will be addressed by the CJEU as soon as possible to provide certainty for data subjects and controllers alike. In that context, the Commissioner acknowledges that many businesses rely on SCCs to transfer data from the EU to the US. It is important to note that today’s decision does not invalidate the SCCs {nor the Privacy Shield); neither does it prohibit their continued use for the purpose of data transfers to the US or elsewhere. Rather, it invites the CJEU to consider whether, under EU law, SCCs in their present form can and should be retained as a basis for the transfer of personal data from the EU to the US.




Executive Summary